China and India: Where They Stand and Where They Are Heading
By CA. S. Muralidharan — Business Mentor and Thought Leader
When we discuss China and India becoming world powers, it is easy to be carried away by population figures, economic growth rates and speeches by political leaders.
But power has a practical meaning. Can a country make the products it needs? Can it develop important technologies? Can it protect its borders and trade routes? Will other countries listen when it speaks?
Judged by these measures, China is well ahead of India today. India is growing in importance, but it still has considerable ground to cover.
Over the next fifteen years, India will probably narrow some of this gap. China, however, is unlikely to stand still. The outcome will depend heavily on how well both countries are governed.
We cannot assume that today’s leaders will remain in office until 2041. We can, however, examine where their present governments are taking them and what is likely to happen if those broad directions continue.
Where China stands today
China has built an enormous industrial system. It produces everything from inexpensive household goods to advanced machinery, batteries, electric vehicles and telecommunications equipment.
Its strength comes from the connections between factories, suppliers, engineers, transport networks and research institutions. Building such a system takes decades.
This gives China influence abroad. A country buying Chinese equipment may also depend on Chinese spare parts, software, maintenance and technical support. These relationships often continue long after the original sale.
China also has substantial military capabilities and the resources to support a wider international presence.
But China has serious problems. Its population is ageing. Its property sector is troubled. Local government finances are under pressure, and many households remain cautious about spending. The IMF has warned that excessive reliance on investment and industrial support has contributed to financial vulnerabilities and inefficient use of resources. (imf.org)
China is therefore a powerful country facing difficult adjustments. Its problems are real, but they do not erase the capabilities it has already built.
What China’s present government does well—and where it can go wrong
Under Xi Jinping, China’s government has placed strong emphasis on national security, industrial strength and technological independence.
One advantage of its system is continuity. Once the leadership decides that an industry is important, it can direct finance, infrastructure, research and administrative attention towards it for many years.
Its current technology priorities include semiconductors, advanced machinery, industrial software, new materials and biomanufacturing. (english.www.gov.cn)
However, strong central control carries risks. When decisions are concentrated at the top, officials may become more concerned with satisfying superiors than reporting uncomfortable facts. A mistaken policy can continue because challenging it is difficult.
Government support can also keep investment flowing into industries that already have too much capacity. The IMF’s recommendation that China give greater room to market forces and reduce preferential treatment for selected firms reflects this concern. (imf.org)
My assessment is that China’s government is particularly effective at concentrating resources on selected national goals. Its harder task is allowing enough independent judgment, business confidence and honest feedback to correct mistakes.
Where India stands today
India has different strengths.
It has a large domestic market, a substantial business community, an internationally connected technology sector and a younger population. Its digital public systems and technical workforce offer opportunities for further development.
The World Bank identifies India’s IT sector, technical talent and digital public infrastructure as advantages in using artificial intelligence for development. (worldbank.org)
India is also useful to many countries. Businesses want access to its consumers. Governments want its cooperation. Companies seeking additional production locations see opportunities in India.
Yet India’s achievements remain uneven. Advanced businesses operate alongside small firms struggling with finance, regulation and basic infrastructure. Excellent institutions exist alongside schools and colleges that do not adequately prepare students for work.
A large economy does not automatically mean that most people have secure, productive employment. The World Bank estimates that around 12 million young people enter India’s labour market each year. Creating enough good jobs is therefore central to its future. (worldbank.org)
India has considerable potential. The question is how much of it becomes productive capacity.
What India’s present government does well—and what remains unfinished
Under Narendra Modi, India has pursued a more visible international role and placed considerable emphasis on infrastructure, digital delivery, investment and national security.
There have also been important economic reforms. The OECD identifies financial inclusion, GST, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and other measures as contributors to growth. It simultaneously points to continuing barriers in trade, investment, employment and public services. (oecd.org)
My assessment is that the government has been effective at setting prominent national priorities and mobilising attention around them. Its record is less consistent when success requires patient improvements across thousands of local institutions.
A highway can be built through a clearly defined project. Improving classroom teaching, making contracts easier to enforce or reducing everyday regulatory uncertainty requires sustained changes in how institutions work.
India’s federal democracy adds complexity. The central government cannot deliver national transformation alone. States, municipalities, courts, universities and private businesses all matter.
Democracy also provides ways to expose mistakes through elections, public debate and scrutiny. These advantages are strongest when criticism is heard and institutions can act independently.
For India’s long-term strength, social cohesion matters as well. Religious or caste divisions become an economic and strategic cost when they weaken trust, distract administration or prevent people from participating fully in national life.
The quality of government should therefore be judged by results: better learning, dependable services, productive jobs, fair administration and predictable rules.
What their foreign policies are likely to seek
China will probably spend the next fifteen years trying to protect and extend its existing strength.
It will seek better technology, secure supplies of energy and minerals, access to overseas markets and greater influence over international decisions. It will also seek to reduce the ability of the United States and its partners to restrict its choices.
India will seek many of the same things, but from a different position. It needs foreign investment, technology and markets to strengthen its domestic economy. It will cooperate with the United States, Europe and Japan while preserving relationships with Russia, Gulf countries and the developing world.
India’s stated approach remains strategic autonomy: choosing partnerships according to its own interests rather than accepting automatic commitments to one side. (sansad.in)
That approach will become harder during a major crisis. Countries may demand support, restrict technology or attach conditions to trade. India’s freedom to choose will be greater if it has several dependable suppliers and stronger capabilities at home.
China faces a different difficulty. Its growing strength can make neighbouring countries anxious. They may trade extensively with China while seeking security cooperation elsewhere.
Both countries must learn that influence depends on whether other nations find cooperation worthwhile.
Africa will be an important test
Africa offers opportunities for both countries, but African governments will increasingly ask what these partnerships deliver for their own people.
China already has a larger presence in infrastructure and industrial supply. India has opportunities in medicines, education, agricultural equipment, digital services and smaller manufacturing businesses.
The need for employment is enormous. The World Bank projects that sub-Saharan Africa will add more than 620 million people to its labour force between 2025 and 2050. (worldbank.org)
A railway is valuable when it helps businesses move goods economically. A factory is valuable when it creates viable jobs and develops local suppliers. Training matters when people can use their skills.
The country that helps African economies produce more will earn more durable goodwill than one that mainly increases its sales.
Where they are most likely to stand in 2041
If present broad directions continue, and neither country is derailed by a major war or prolonged crisis, China will probably remain stronger overall in 2041.
It is likely to retain a substantial advantage in manufacturing, advanced industrial capabilities and military reach. Slower growth will make its choices harder, but it will still possess a formidable base.
India is likely to be wealthier, more influential and more important to international business. It could become a stronger manufacturing centre and a more capable power in the Indian Ocean.
But the size of its advance depends on the quality of its development. If education, employment, research and administration improve only gradually, India may become a much larger economy while remaining dependent on others for crucial technologies.
For ordinary Indians, this means that national success must be measured through changes in everyday life: whether young people find worthwhile work, businesses can expand, women have better opportunities, and public institutions work reliably.
China’s challenge is to preserve innovation and prosperity while managing the risks of excessive control. India’s challenge is to turn ambition and democratic energy into consistent delivery.
China has already built much of the machinery of a great power. India is still building it. Over the next fifteen years, the quality of government will determine how effectively each country uses its people, resources and opportunities.