Was there Knowledge Before Modern Science
How earlier societies discovered what worked
CA. S. Muralidharan | Business Mentor and Thought Leader
When we think of a scientist, we usually picture someone in a laboratory, surrounded by instruments. But people were making important discoveries long before laboratories existed.
They watched the sky, worked with metals and learned how to make cloth hold its colour. They tested ideas through calculation and daily practice. Over generations, they built knowledge that others could use.
India’s achievements raise a fair question. If our ancestors could make fine steel, extract zinc and calculate eclipses, could they also have understood more about time, matter and the universe than we now recognise?
We should take that question seriously. Their achievements give us good reason to investigate. We also need to look closely at the evidence for each claim.
Knowledge at the furnace and the loom
At Zawar in Rajasthan, metalworkers extracted zinc through a difficult process. At the heat needed to release it from ore, zinc readily turns into vapour. The workers had to collect that vapour and cool it into metal while limiting its reaction with air. Remains of furnaces and ceramic vessels show that they succeeded during the medieval period. [1]
They knew how to obtain zinc before anyone explained their process through modern chemistry. Each successful batch gave them practical evidence that their method worked.
South Indian steelmakers developed another demanding skill. Using special vessels called crucibles, they made the high-carbon steel known as wootz. They had to choose suitable materials and carefully manage the furnace. Modern researchers can study the steel’s structure, but its makers already knew how to produce a valued material. [2]
Indian weavers and dyers also worked with knowledge built through experience. They understood fibres, colouring materials and the treatments that helped dyes stay on cloth. Their cotton fabrics found buyers across Asia, Africa and Europe. [3]
These achievements did not all happen at the same time. Wootz had ancient roots. The strongest early evidence for zinc distillation at Zawar is medieval. Much of the evidence for India’s leading role in international cotton markets comes from the medieval and early modern periods. Those dates help us understand how knowledge developed.
How people knew what worked
Imagine a skilled metalworker watching a furnace. Its colour, the appearance of the material and the result of earlier batches might guide the next decision. A written temperature reading would make that judgment easier to record, but experience could still make it reliable.
Such skills could pass from teacher to apprentice. The learner watched, practised, made mistakes and tried again. Knowledge could survive in the hands and judgment of people who left no books behind.
We should therefore ask three separate questions. How did someone discover a method? How did they check that it worked? And how did they explain the result?
The answers may differ. A useful method might emerge from repeated trials. Its explanation might come much later. A mistaken explanation does not erase a successful skill, although it may limit what people can do next.
Indian thinkers also asked how knowledge could be trusted. They discussed pramana, or the means of knowing. Different schools gave different weight to observation, inference, testimony and other forms of reasoning. They did not all agree.
An unfamiliar method deserves a fair hearing. We can ask what it achieves, when it fails and how its results can be checked. The route to a discovery may vary. What matters is whether the knowledge proves dependable.
Thinking about immense stretches of time
Indian traditions imagined time on a scale far beyond a human lifetime. In the Surya Siddhanta, the four yugas together form a mahayuga of 4.32 million years. A thousand mahayugas make a kalpa of 4.32 billion years. The scale of this thinking deserves attention. [4]
A kalpa, however, is a period in a traditional cosmic account. Before comparing it with a modern number, we must ask what each number describes.
Scientists estimate Earth’s age at about 4.54 billion years and the universe’s age at about 13.8 billion years. These estimates come from physical evidence and models. They answer different questions from the traditional description of a kalpa. [5, 6]
A similarity between numbers is worth examining. To show that it reflects the same discovery, we would need to understand how the ancient number was obtained and what its author meant.
The same care is needed with very small units of time. Defining a tiny interval shows mathematical thought. Establishing that people measured it requires evidence about how they did so. Both questions are worth pursuing.
Calculations we can still examine
Ancient astronomy gives us something especially useful: calculations that can be studied today.
Aryabhata’s Aryabhatiya, composed in 499 CE, includes mathematical methods and a sine table. It explains eclipses through shadows and describes Earth’s rotation as the reason the heavens appear to move around us each day. These are specific ideas we can examine. [7]
The Surya Siddhanta also gives numerical methods for tracking celestial movements and keeping time. We can work through those methods and compare their results with observations. Some calculations may work well even where the larger explanation needs correction. [4]
Brahmagupta later set out rules involving zero and negative numbers and developed algebraic methods. His work was a major contribution to a longer history. Calling him the sole inventor of zero would leave out that wider development. [8]
These examples show that earlier knowledge could already be precise and mathematical. Studying the actual calculations tells us more than making broad claims about ancient wisdom.
Ideas about matter and life
The Vaisheshika tradition associated with Kanada tried to explain matter through atoms and their combinations. It also examined qualities, motion and other aspects of existence. This was a serious attempt to understand the world. Its ideas developed through texts and commentaries over time. [9]
The idea that visible objects are made of tiny constituents was an important insight. Whether a particular passage also describes something like a nucleus or quantum behaviour is a further question. We need evidence specific enough to establish that connection.
Words need similar care. Akasha, prana and shakti carry meanings within particular traditions. Translating them as space or energy can help an English reader, but the translation alone cannot show that they mean exactly what those words mean in physics.
The Prashna Upanishad, for instance, discusses prana in relation to life, bodily functions and the self. We should first understand that account in its own setting. Then we can explore any comparison with modern knowledge. [10]
Inner experience also deserves thoughtful study. An experience during contemplation can tell us something about the person’s awareness. If we say it reveals a physical fact about the universe, we need a way to check that further claim. Keeping those questions clear allows investigation to remain open.
Knowledge across civilisations
Other societies also found ways to understand and work with nature. Babylonian astronomers developed calculations for celestial movements. Surviving tablets include geometric methods for calculating Jupiter’s movement. [11]
Greek makers built the Antikythera mechanism, an astronomical calculator with gears that tracked calendar and eclipse cycles. We still do not know who designed and made it. Eratosthenes estimated Earth’s circumference using solar angles and distance. [12, 13]
Chinese workers developed advanced cast-iron production and silk-making traditions. In the medieval Islamic world, Ibn al-Haytham studied light through experiments and mathematics. Al-Jazari described water clocks and mechanical devices, including machines designed to perform actions automatically. [14–17]
In Mesoamerica, Maya astronomers and scribes developed sophisticated systems of numbers and calendars. [18]
Each tradition had particular strengths. India’s early zinc production remains an achievement even when we recognise excellence elsewhere. Knowledge also travelled through trade and translation. We need evidence to distinguish an independent discovery from an idea learned and developed through contact.
Could knowledge have been lost
Yes, some knowledge may have been lost. A written description may leave out the detail that an experienced worker knew by touch or sight. A surviving object can show that people had a skill even when we cannot recover every step.
But the possibility of loss cannot tell us what the missing knowledge contained. We must look for traces in tools, manuscripts, materials and production sites. Sometimes rebuilding a process can help us understand it.
India’s achievements give us sound reasons to investigate its other ideas seriously. They show what its thinkers and practitioners were capable of. To establish a particular discovery, we still need evidence connected to that discovery.
Modern researchers can overlook evidence or dismiss unfamiliar ideas too quickly. Their methods also have limits. Those weaknesses should encourage better research. They leave room for questions; they do not settle the answers.
Where the evidence is incomplete, we can say so. Leaving a question open is more useful than pretending to know either that an achievement existed or that it was impossible.
Giving earlier knowledge its due
We should remember the people whose names have disappeared. The makers of furnaces, instruments and dyes may have contributed as much as a scholar whose manuscript survives. A fair history needs room for them.
We should also ask who first thought of an idea, who made it work reliably and who explained why it worked. Those achievements may belong to different people, separated by centuries.
Modern science grew within this longer history of human learning. It can help explain and test earlier knowledge. Yet a later explanation was never what first made a successful process work or a correct calculation useful.
For me, this is the strongest reason to study the subject. We should approach earlier traditions with respect and curiosity, recover the evidence carefully, and remain willing to learn from methods we do not yet fully understand.
Sources and further reading
Numbered references support the historical examples. Interpretations about discovery and validation are the argument of this essay. Ancient texts often survive in later copies and translations; attribution and dating require care.
[1] Ancient zinc smelting in the Upper and Middle Yangtze River region
[2] Srinivasan Ultrahigh carbon wootz from crucible carburization of molten iron
[3] Victoria and Albert Museum Indian textiles
[4] Surya Siddhanta Burgess translation Chapter 1
[5] NIST How do you know the age of fossils and other old things
[6] NASA How old is the universe
[7] Aryabhatiya English translation
[8] University of St Andrews Brahmagupta
[9] Vaisheshika Sutra with commentary English translation
[10] Prashna Upanishad Translation by Sri Aurobindo
[11] Ossendrijver Ancient Babylonian astronomers calculated Jupiter’s position
[12] Freeth and colleagues Decoding the Antikythera Mechanism
[13] NOAA The history of geodesy
[14] Cast iron smelting furnace materials in imperial China
[15] UNESCO Sericulture and silk craftsmanship of China
[16] UNESCO Ibn al Haytham’s scientific method
[17] Smithsonian Folio depicting a musical automaton by al Jazari
[18] Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian Living Maya Time